Interim Public Works Director Art Villarreal gives a presentation on fluoride during the city council meeting on Monday, Nov. 9. Villarreal told the council the city stopped adding fluoride to its drinking water in 2017. (Photo by Karen Gleason)

NEWS — Council to decide on fluoride addition to city drinking water

By Karen Gleason
The 830 Times

To add or not to add? That is the question city council members will have to answer regarding fluoride in the city’s drinking water.

Del Rio City Council members discussed the fluoride issue during their regular meeting on Monday, Nov. 9, after hearing a presentation from Art Villarreal, the city’s interim public works director.

Villarreal told the council, “Tonight I’ll review fluoride in Del Rio’s water system, the condition of our equipment, and the consideration for resuming or permanently discontinuing fluoride. The discussion covers why fluoride was added, why its use stopped and what would be needed to resume it. We’ll also consider what continuing without fluoride injection means to the community.”

Villarreal said fluoride is a mineral that occurs naturally and is known to strengthen tooth enamel and prevent tooth decay. He said hydrofluorosilicic acid is the liquid form of fluoride that can be dosed into a city’s drinking water.

Villarreal said fluoride is found naturally in groundwater and springs. He said the San Felipe Springs, the source of all the city’s drinking water, contains natural fluoride averaging 0.2 milligrams per liter, or parts per million. He said fluoride occurs in many fruits and vegetables, as well as in seafood and tea. It is also added to toothpaste and mouthwash.

Villarreal reviewed the process by which the city injected fluoride into its drinking water in the past. He said fluoride is precisely dosed into the water after it is filtered to meet a recommended residual of 0.7 milligrams per liter. He added water “is continuously monitored before filtration, after filtration and before distributing to ensure safe levels.”

He told the council, “The purpose of adding fluoride is dental health. … Choosing whether to add fluoride is a public health policy decision.”

Villarreal listed chemical supply, budget pressures and aging infrastructure as reasons why the city stopped injecting fluoride into its drinking water about five years ago.

Villarreal said the COVID-19 pandemic “created massive supply chain disruptions causing (the cost of) all treatment chemicals to skyrocket.” He said today, water-grade fluoride, the chemical he identified as HSF, is “incredibly difficult to secure.”

Villarreal then addressed the infrastructure that would be needed if the city were to decide to restart fluoride injection. He said the storage area and the tank for the chemical have both deteriorated.

“These conditions would need to be addressed before restarting the system,” Villarreal said.

He said, “Restarting fluoridation would require addressing the storage and feed equipment, verifying proper dosing and securing a dependable chemical supplier. The evaluation should include both the initial work and the continuing cost of operation.

“Continuing without fluoride injection would avoid the proposed restart investment and ongoing fluoride chemical expenses. Resuming would involve capital costs, chemical purchase, monitoring and maintenance. Those expenses should be considered alongside the dental health purpose of the program,” Villarreal added.

He said the two options city staff is presenting are permanently discontinuing fluoride injection or restarting the program.

“The decision should consider public health, long-term operating costs, regulatory compliance and community priorities,” Villarreal said.

He said the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality does not require every Texas public water system to add fluoride. If the city elects to resume fluoridation, it will be subject to applicable TCEQ regulations.

Following the presentation, Villarreal asked if there were any questions.

Councilman Leno Hernandez began by asking Villarreal when the city started fluoridation, and Villarreal replied it was in 2006.

Hernandez said, “We don’t have any data that tells us the pros and the cons of what life was before the addition of fluoride until today?”

Villarreal replied, “At the water plant, it was just monitoring levels and making sure they were the correct doses that were set by the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency).”

Hernandez then asked if the question of whether the city should restart fluoridation or permanently discontinue the practice would be brought back before the council.

City Manager Manuel Chavez said, “We wanted to kind of present this as far as our current state. I know that it’s been brought up here most recently, and the idea for this particular presentation was just to make you aware that currently it’s not being injected, mainly because the equipment needs to be replaced, repaired, and, if this is something we want to continue, then definitely we need to bring it back.

“It is costly. It’s been introduced in budget, as early as 2021,” Chavez added.

Villarreal interjected with some data about costs researched by city staff and added that currently most suppliers of the chemical are located overseas. He said it would cost about $300,000 to ready the equipment and storage facilities needed to restart fluoridation.

Hernandez reiterated Villarreal’s presentation did not include data on the pros and cons.

He said, “There was no pros and cons to tell us whether or not we need it, whether or not we’re benefitting from it being in our system or not, so that we can make that decision whether or not it’s worth the investment. We were just told how expensive it is and how low the supply is.”

The councilman said whenever the issue is brought back to council, he would like to see “actual data” regarding dental health before and after fluoride was added to the city’s water system.

“There have to be some studies out there that are going to help us decide whether we need to make these types of investments or not,” Hernandez said and asked Chavez to provide the council with that information.

Mayor Al Arreola asked when the city stopped adding fluoride to its water, and Villarreal replied it was in 2017-2018.

Councilwoman Elsa Reyes speculated the city may have started adding fluoride because at the time there were not as many products with fluoride in them.

Arreola said citizens over the past 20 years have approached the city about not adding fluoride to the city’s drinking water, noting some fluoride occurs naturally in the spring water that is the city’s source of drinking water.

He then recognized Councilwoman Carmen Gutierrez.

Gutierrez, reading from prepared notes, said, “On June 30, 2005, a group named Environment Concerned Citizens, led by myself and Ms. Rosalinda Sanchez, came before council because at that time, council had already approved the addition of fluoride into our water system, and we came with facts, detailed information from the Centers for Disease Control and everything, and that particular council voted to stop the addition of fluoride.

“Two weeks later, due to influence by an outside organization and some dental professionals, it was reinstated. That decision to stop adding fluoride into our water system was rescinded and it began again. On Sept. 12, 2006, John Morony, environmental specialist, came before council, speaking to the toxicity of fluoride addition to our water system.

“On Oct. 24, 2006, Fluoride Action Network, led by Bob DeNorr, also came and spoke about the fluoride toxicity that has been in existence for nearly 25 years. In 2017, the city of Del Rio went ahead and stopped due to issues resulting in having to redo the facility and upgrade equipment. Fluoride ate up the equipment.

“From July to August this year, I have had requests to add this item to the agenda. So it’s time. I’d like to ask the city manager to add the discussion of and possible action on to permanently remove fluoride from the water system. HSF is highly corrosive. If it’s going to corrode the equipment that we have out there in the water filtration system, can you imagine what it would do to our bodies?

“But it’s not my decision alone. It’s something that each and every citizen needs to decide and they need to decide vocally. If at that time council cannot decide, maybe future action would be to put it on a ballot, a referendum, and that would be a different option, but I would like to see the discussion and possible permanent removal of fluoride in the water system.

“As of right now, they’re not adding it. So that’s good. … If you look at the dental, and I know they talked about the dental, there is a warning label on our toothpaste that says, ‘poison control.’ And I’m not saying it’s my opinion, but there are established records of high incidents of dementia, thyroid illness, endocrine disorders, higher and higher increasing in this area,” Gutierrez said.

She finished, “It is a public health decision, and it is a public health choice, and hopefully we can hear from our citizens at that time.”

Arreola noted the city “will remain where we’re at” until Chavez brings the issue back before the council. Chavez said based on the evening’s discussion, he would bring back an action item on the issue, “with more information that has been available since 2006.”

The writer can be reached at delriomagnoliafan@gmail.com.

 

Joel Langton

Leave a Reply

Receive the latest news

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

And get information about All of Del Rio’s events delivered directly to your inbox!