By Karen Gleason
The 830 Times
City council members have approved moving forward with a plan requested by the local public school district to temporarily close a portion of Waters Avenue adjacent to San Felipe Memorial Middle School during school hours.
City council members voted on the temporary road closure plan during their most recent regular meeting on Monday, Nov. 9.
City Secretary Mari Acosta read the heading of the agenda item: “Discussion and possible action to consider the request made by San Felipe Del Rio CISD to close a portion of Waters Avenue between the hours of 6:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. when the San Felipe Memorial Middle School is in session to support safety and campus security operations.”
After Acosta read the heading, Mayor Al Arreola recognized City Manager Manuel Chavez.
Chavez told the council, “I did have a request from school district Superintendent Dr. Carlos Rios to have this item on the agenda for your consideration. This item has been brought forward in a different capacity. Dr. Rios wants to request the Waters Avenue to be closed, not on a permanent basis, but during particular school hours, and that’s something that our staff met with the school district to kind of go over that particular scenario.
“There are some things that the city requested in order to have access, and Dr. Rios did mention that anything that was requested would be available for the city. At that point, we don’t see any other concerns. We did want to bring this forward. Dr. Rios is here, if he wants to go over any of the requests. We are in agreement that this is something that could work for all of us, and, again, this would also help in the sense of safety concerns that the school district has had, along with the city, so this seems to be a workable request,” Chavez added.
Arreola then recognized Rios and Josh Overfelt, president of the SFDRCISD Board of Trustees.
Rios thanked Arreola for the opportunity to address the council and make the request for the temporary closure of a portion of Waters Avenue in person.
Rios said he had a short presentation developed by staff that he felt would clarify the request further. Rios said he and Overfelt were also joined by Linda Guanajuato Webb, like Overfelt an elected member of the SFDRCISD Board of Trustees, and by Charles Garabedian, the district’s chief administrative officer.
Rios said, “We’re asking the council to consider a temporary, a partial, closure of Waters Avenue. Our ask is simply that we be allowed to build gates at both ends (of the closure area), about 15-20 feet into Waters Avenue (from its intersection with Garza Street), stretching across, and at the very end of our property, which is right at the edge of the Phil Ricks Gym and that that gate be shut from 6:30 in the morning to approximately 5:30 in the afternoon.
“The ask is primarily for the safety of the students. If allowed to close the street during the school hours, we would build a loop where kids could be dropped off and picked up (on the vacant lot next to the gym). So by closing the street, we’re not putting the traffic on Garza Street or on any other street,” Rios added.
Rios showed a photo of the type of gate that would be used and reiterated the school district’s request was primarily for student safety.
He said the school district is planning to build a cafeteria and a second gym on the vacant lot adjacent to the Phil Ricks Gym. He said students currently walk back and forth across Waters Avenue to access the gym, creating safety and security concerns.
Rios said, “At the school district, we believe providing safety to our students is a layered measure. We have fences around all of our schools. You can’t just drive up and have direct access to a classroom where students are. You have to go through a single point of entry.
“The second layer of defense is obviously the building itself, and the third is security officers. In the case of the gym, there is no layered security because a car can drive up straight to the gym and have direct access. When we build the cafeteria and the second gym, it would be the same, but by building the fence, it forces people to that single point of entry,” Rios said.
He added, “And because it’s only a partial closing during the day, traffic can flow freely after school hours, on weekends or any day there are school holidays.”
Rios said a permanent closure was discussed, but after meeting with city administrators, it was agreed that the proposed temporary closure “would suffice for our needs.”
Arreola said a concern voiced to him by some citizens was a question about who would be patrolling the area to ensure the smooth flow of traffic, and Rios said that has always been the responsibility of the school district’s police department.
Councilwoman Carmen Gutierrez thanked Rios for meeting with citizens about the proposed closure and answering questions about the initiative.
Gutierrez asked, “Once someone saw this on the agenda they called me and asked how would an emergency vehicle access an emergency at Ricks (Gym) or in that neighborhood if both gates were closed?”
Rios replied, “In this case it would be easier. If you consider any other campus, for example, Del Rio High School. If something were to happen in the gym, somebody would have to go open the gate. In this case it would be no different, and the proximity of the gate to the gym is closer. But that holds true at any of our campuses. Accessing the interior of the grounds is always going to require a gate be opened. This would be no different.”
Rios added all emergency first responders in the area would have access, whether by keys or cards.
Chavez told the council that when he met with school district officials about the initiative, members of the police department and the fire department were part of the discussions.
“They were able to address any issues, and Dr. Rios did mention that they would always have access, whether it’s through a key or a card. The staff did have some of those concerns, and those concerns were addressed,” Chavez said.
Councilman LeRoy Briones commented, “I want to thank the school district for really putting homework into this. I know when you had the town hall and people came out, the biggest rebuttal I got from the community was that permanent closure. I’m on board 100 percent because I came from across the street from a school that had the worst tragedy in the world.
“Safety for me is top priority. I feel that this project and the common median that the city and the school district have come up with, temporary, with gates being able to be opened and closed, is a great compromise to permanent closure. My only thing is that we would be able to, as Councilwoman Gutierrez said, that we would facilitate that key exchange between different organizations, and I know that sounds really silly, but it’s so silly that it could be an oversight, and during an emergency no one has a key to open that gate,” Briones said.
He also praised Rios and the school district for addressing the situation, saying, “You’re 100 percent right, people have direct access to our kids on that street, and it’s always been that way. People can go straight into the gym. Even when I was in school, there were incidents where there were people in the gym who didn’t belong in the gym, so this would be a way for you guys to protect our children.”
Councilman Leno Hernandez said he echoed Briones’ remarks and commended Rios and the school board for their outreach to citizens and discussions about the project.
Arreola asked Rios when he planned to start work on the gates if the council approved the request.
“Tomorrow,” Rios said, adding the school district would begin taking bids for the construction of the gates. He said he would immediately begin preparing a recommendation for the school board and information for parents.
Arreola also asked what would happen “if something happened to make this thing go south,” and Rios said the street would always belong to the city.
“We are not erecting anything that will be permanent,” Rios added.
Hernandez then made a motion to authorize Chavez to cooperate with the school district to develop a temporary street closure plan and return to city council with a final recommendation and any required implementing documents.
Councilman J.P. Sanchez gave the second, and the council voted unanimously to approve the motion.
Hernandez then also thanked Rios, a veteran of the U.S. Navy, for his service in advance of Veterans Day.
The writer can be reached at delriomagnoliafan@gmail.com.
Editor’s note: I corrected “The 80 Times” and adjusted the headline and opening to reflect the motion described: approval to develop a closure plan and return to council with a final recommendation.


